1 / 14

35 West Chester Street, Nantucket MA 02554

ActiveTown1 FamilySingle Family Residence

$3,800,000

$1,979 / sqft

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

1 + 1 half

Sq Ft

1,920

Lot

0.1885 acres

Year Built

1925

Days on Market

342

Description

Three bedroom antique home and garage nestled between West Chester Street and Sunset Hill Road. Set on an oversized lot this property has almost 2,000 square feet of remaining ground cover. Near Lily Pond Park and the Oldest House, it offers a level of privacy that is rare for properties in the Residential Old Historic District. The house is located within the highest portion of the lot, approximately 40 feet, along Sunset Hill Road, offering a nice view toward Lily Pond Park. The garage is situated just off West Chester at approximately 20 feet.

Property Details

MLS #91936

StatusActive

Property Type1 Family

Sub TypeSingle Family Residence

NeighborhoodTown

MLS AreaTown

CityNantucket

StateMA

Zip02554

List Price$3,800,000

Original List Price$4,800,000

Price / Sq Ft$1,979

Bedrooms3

Full Baths1

Half Baths1

Total Rooms7

Living Area1,920 sqft

Lot Size0.1885 acres

Year Built1925

Days on Market342

ZoningROH

FurnishedUnfurnished

FireplacesOne

PoolNo

GarageYes

SewerTwn

Water SourceTown

Second DwellingP/Sd

OwnerCharles & John Tooker

Parcel #149

Tax Map #41

Annual Tax$9,598

Assessed Value$1,296,100

Tax Year2025

On Market DateFeb 8, 2025

First ListedMay 4, 2026

Last UpdatedMay 4, 2026

Latitude41.2871273

Longitude-70.1071672

Heating

OFHW

Parking

Yes

View

NoneTwn

Utilities

Cbl

Flooring

Oak

Appliances

Stove: electric rangeWasher: Maytag

Interior Features

Floor 1: Kitchen, half bath, dining room, living room with fireplace, sunroom.Floor 2: Three bedrooms and one full bathroom.

Foundation

Concrete

Basement

Fullunfinished basement with laundry and exterior access.

Lot Features

None knownYes

Additional MLS Details

SewerTwn

ZoningROH

Tax Year2025

BasementFull, unfinished basement with laundry and exterior access.

FlooringOak

Garage YNtrue

LINK Psf1979.1666

FurnishedUnfurnished

Owner NameCharles & John Tooker

AppliancesStove: electric range, Washer: Maytag

Rooms Total7

Lot FeaturesNone known, Yes

Water SourceTown

On Market Date2025-02-08

Parcel Number149

Tax Map Number41

Pool Private YNfalse

Tax Annual Amount9598

Interior FeaturesFloor 1: Kitchen, half bath, dining room, living room with fireplace, sunroom., Floor 2: Three bedrooms and one full bathroom.

Tax Assessed Value1296100

Fireplace FeaturesOne

Foundation DetailsConcrete

Original List Price4800000

LINK Listing Dwell2P/Sd

Price Change Timestamp2025-03-17T12:44:21.947Z

Original Entry Timestamp2025-02-03T12:46:27.077Z

Listing Agent

Liz Finlay

Great Point Properties

Price History

Date	Event	Price	Change
May 4, 2026	Listed	$3,800,000

Tax History

Year	Tax Amount	Assessed Value	Land	Improvements
2025	$9,598	$1,296,100	—	—

Market Context

Town Avg

$5,409,833

Town Median

$4,772,500

Island Avg

$6,064,676

Island Median

$4,299,000

Property Context

Wetlands NearbyNo

Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.

MLS Listing #91936 — Data as of 2026-05-04