← All properties
1 / 22
1 / 2267 Vestal Street, Nantucket MA 02554
ActiveWest of Town1 FamilySingle Family Residence
$11,950,000
$2,577 / sqft
Bedrooms
5
Bathrooms
5 + 2 half
Sq Ft
4,638
Lot
0.6048 acres
Year Built
2026
Days on Market
18
Description
On an oversized 26,000-square-foot lot in 20,000 sq.ft. zoning that is situated along coveted Vestal Street, 67 Vestal is a stunning turnkey newly constructed Nantucket retreat. It blends refined coastal design with exceptional functionality and comfort. Surrounded by landscaped grounds and designed with a soothing, sophisticated palette throughout, this well crafted home offers expansive indoor-outdoor living complete with a heated pool, pool cabana, bluestone patios, and multiple outdoor entertaining spaces. Wide oak flooring, elevated architectural details, and abundant natural light create a warm and welcoming atmosphere across every level. With five finished bedroom suites and additional available footprint for a future garage, guest house, or expansion, this exceptional property offers both immediate enjoyment and long-term flexibility in one of Nantucket’s most desirable locations.
Property Details
MLS #92485
StatusActive
Property Type1 Family
Sub TypeSingle Family Residence
NeighborhoodWest of Town
MLS AreaWest of Town
CityNantucket
StateMA
Zip02554
List Price$11,950,000
Price / Sq Ft$2,577
Bedrooms5
Full Baths5
Half Baths2
Total Rooms10
Living Area4,638 sqft
Lot Size0.6048 acres
Year Built2026
Days on Market18
ZoningR20
FurnishedUnfurnished
FireplacesNo
PoolNo
GarageNo
SewerTwn
Water SourceWell
Second DwellingP/Sd
Owner67 Vestal LLC
Parcel #59
Tax Map #41
Annual Tax$4,975
Assessed Value$347,100
Tax Year2026
On Market DateJun 10, 2026
First ListedJun 11, 2026
Last UpdatedJul 3, 2026
Latitude41.2794969
Longitude-70.1144623
Parking
Ample
Exterior
P/PoolPatioPorch
View
NoneRes
Utilities
None
Flooring
Wood/Tile
Appliances
Stove: YesWasher: Two
Interior Features
AC,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: A wraparound porch and bluestone walkway create a gracious arrival to the home, where refined architectural details and a calming interior palette immediately set the tone. The welcoming foyer opens to a private office framed by thoughtful millwork and natural light, while wide oak floors and seven-foot doors carry throughout the level. A beautifully designed transition hall leads to the mudroom and laundry area, featuring heated tile floors, custom storage, and direct access to the outdoor shower, pool area, and lower-level entrance. Adjacent, a fully outfitted appliance pantry with pocket doors offers exceptional functionality with additional refrigeration, dishwasher, prep sink, beverage refrigerator, and extensive storage. At the heart of the home, the kitchen combines timeless craftsmanship with modern luxury, featuring stone countertops, a multi-burner induction range with griddle, dual ovens, wide country sink, and generous custom cabinetry. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the casual living area, where oversized sliders overlook the pool and outdoor entertaining spaces. A separate formal living room and dining area are positioned to capture beautiful
natural light through expansive Andersen windows and large sliding doors opening onto the rear patio and lawn
beyond. Outdoor spaces include a covered dining trellis, grilling area, and multiple seating areas thoughtfully designed for entertaining and enjoying Nantucket sunsets. Privately positioned on the first floor, a stunning bedroom suite features vaulted ceilings with shiplap detailing, a beautifully built-out walk-in closet, and a luxurious en suite bathroom with heated tile floors, dual vanities, soaking tub, private water closet, and large walk-in shower with direct access to a private outdoor shower.Floor 2: The second level features three beautifully appointed en suite bedrooms thoughtfully designed to provide comfort, privacy, and abundant natural light. A cozy reading nook on the landing creates an inviting transition space, while elevated ceiling heights and refined finishes enhance the airy feel throughout the floor. The primary suite overlooks the rear of the property and offers exceptional privacy, natural light, and a fully built-out walk-in closet. Its en suite bathroom includes dual vanities, marble finishes, and a walk-in shower with bench seating and privacy glass windows that allow sunlight to fill the space while maintaining comfort and seclusion. A second bedroom is ideally suited for guests and includes built-in charging stations and a beautifully finished en suite bathroom. The third bedroom also features a private en suite bath with refined detailing and walk-in shower. Thoughtful architectural lines and detailing further elevate the second-floor living experience.
Basement
The lower level offers expansive additional living space designed for recreationentertainmentand flexible guest accommodations. A large media and gathering room provides ample space for movie nightsgamesor casual lounging. Also located on this level is a spacious bedroom suite with a large bathroombeautifully finished tile workand generous storage. The bedroom is sizable enough to accommodate multiple bunk configurations or additional guest arrangements. A second laundry areatidy utility roomand extensive storage further enhance the practicality of the level. An additional unfinished room with plumbing already in place offers tremendous flexibility for a future bedroomgymspa roomor wellness space depending on a future owner’s vision.
Lot Features
See Deed Certificate 27998Beautifully landscaped
Additional MLS Details
SewerTwn
ZoningR20
Tax Year2026
BasementThe lower level offers expansive additional living space designed for recreation, entertainment, and flexible guest accommodations. A large media and gathering room provides ample space for movie nights, games, or casual lounging. Also located on this level is a spacious bedroom suite with a large bathroom, beautifully finished tile work, and generous storage. The bedroom is sizable enough to accommodate multiple bunk configurations or additional guest arrangements. A second laundry area, tidy utility room, and extensive storage further enhance the practicality of the level. An additional unfinished room with plumbing already in place offers tremendous flexibility for a future bedroom, gym, spa room, or wellness space depending on a future owner’s vision.
FlooringWood/Tile
Garage YNfalse
LINK Psf2576.5416
FurnishedUnfurnished
Owner Name67 Vestal LLC
AppliancesStove: Yes, Washer: Two
Rooms Total10
Lot FeaturesSee Deed Certificate 27998, Beautifully landscaped
Water SourceWell
On Market Date2026-06-10
Parcel Number59
Tax Map Number41
Pool Private YNfalse
Tax Annual Amount4975
Interior FeaturesAC,Ins,Irr,OSh, Floor 1: A wraparound porch and bluestone walkway create a gracious arrival to the home, where refined architectural details and a calming interior palette immediately set the tone. The welcoming foyer opens to a private office framed by thoughtful millwork and natural light, while wide oak floors and seven-foot doors carry throughout the level. A beautifully designed transition hall leads to the mudroom and laundry area, featuring heated tile floors, custom storage, and direct access to the outdoor shower, pool area, and lower-level entrance. Adjacent, a fully outfitted appliance pantry with pocket doors offers exceptional functionality with additional refrigeration, dishwasher, prep sink, beverage refrigerator, and extensive storage. At the heart of the home, the kitchen combines timeless craftsmanship with modern luxury, featuring stone countertops, a multi-burner induction range with griddle, dual ovens, wide country sink, and generous custom cabinetry. The kitchen flows seamlessly into the casual living area, where oversized sliders overlook the pool and outdoor entertaining spaces. A separate formal living room and dining area are positioned to capture beautiful
natural light through expansive Andersen windows and large sliding doors opening onto the rear patio and lawn
beyond. Outdoor spaces include a covered dining trellis, grilling area, and multiple seating areas thoughtfully designed for entertaining and enjoying Nantucket sunsets. Privately positioned on the first floor, a stunning bedroom suite features vaulted ceilings with shiplap detailing, a beautifully built-out walk-in closet, and a luxurious en suite bathroom with heated tile floors, dual vanities, soaking tub, private water closet, and large walk-in shower with direct access to a private outdoor shower., Floor 2: The second level features three beautifully appointed en suite bedrooms thoughtfully designed to provide comfort, privacy, and abundant natural light. A cozy reading nook on the landing creates an inviting transition space, while elevated ceiling heights and refined finishes enhance the airy feel throughout the floor. The primary suite overlooks the rear of the property and offers exceptional privacy, natural light, and a fully built-out walk-in closet. Its en suite bathroom includes dual vanities, marble finishes, and a walk-in shower with bench seating and privacy glass windows that allow sunlight to fill the space while maintaining comfort and seclusion. A second bedroom is ideally suited for guests and includes built-in charging stations and a beautifully finished en suite bathroom. The third bedroom also features a private en suite bath with refined detailing and walk-in shower. Thoughtful architectural lines and detailing further elevate the second-floor living experience.
Tax Assessed Value347100
Fireplace FeaturesNo
Original List Price11950000
LINK Listing Dwell2P/Sd
Original Entry Timestamp2025-07-28T17:37:21.147Z
Listing Agent
Brian Sullivan
Fisher Real Estate
Price History
| Date | Event | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 11, 2026 | Listed | $11,950,000 |
Sales History
| Date | Sale Price | List Price | Buyer | MLS # |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan 10, 2025 | $3,200,000 | $3,200,000 | 67 VESTAL LLC | 91893 |
| Nov 16, 2020 | $1,850,000 | $1,850,000 | Vestal Ventures LLC | 87586 |
Tax History
| Year | Tax Amount | Assessed Value | Land | Improvements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $4,975 | $347,100 | — | — |
Market Context
West of Town Avg
$5,676,000
West of Town Median
$3,990,000
Island Avg
$6,935,068
Island Median
$4,950,000
Property Context
Wetlands NearbyNo
Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.
MLS Listing #92485 — Data as of 2026-07-03