← All properties
1 / 24
1 / 2443 Vestal Street, Nantucket MA 02554
ActiveWest of Town1 FamilySingle Family Residence
$7,995,000
$2,706 / sqft
Bedrooms
4
Bathrooms
5 + 1 half
Sq Ft
2,954
Lot
0.46 acres
Year Built
2005
Days on Market
18
Description
Located on a quiet stretch of Vestal Street with close proximity to Town, 43 Vestal offers a thoughtfully designed Nantucket retreat set on a generous 20,000 square foot corner lot. Surrounded by mature landscaping and privacy screening, the property combines expansive outdoor living with a relaxed yet refined coastal aesthetic. The spacious yard includes a heated pool, pool cabana, bluestone patio, and ample room for recreation and entertaining. Beautifully updated interiors feature bright, airy living spaces, refined finishes, and seamless indoor-outdoor flow throughout. With multiple living areas, and a layout designed for both comfort and entertaining, 43 Vestal captures the essence of elevated Nantucket living just moments from Town and nearby conservation land.
Property Details
MLS #92676
StatusActive
Property Type1 Family
Sub TypeSingle Family Residence
NeighborhoodWest of Town
MLS AreaWest of Town
CityNantucket
StateMA
Zip02554
List Price$7,995,000
Price / Sq Ft$2,706
Bedrooms4
Full Baths5
Half Baths1
Total Rooms9
Living Area2,954 sqft
Lot Size0.46 acres
Year Built2005
Days on Market18
ZoningR20
FurnishedUnfurnished
FireplacesGas
PoolNo
GarageNo
SewerTwn
Water SourceTown
Second DwellingNone
OwnerHigh Tide Homes LLC
Parcel #592
Tax Map #41
Annual Tax$16,041
Assessed Value$3,362,800
Tax Year2026
On Market DateJun 10, 2026
First ListedJun 11, 2026
Last UpdatedJul 3, 2026
Latitude41.2801224
Longitude-70.1104852
Heating
GFHA
Parking
Ample
Exterior
P/PoolPorchPatio
View
NoneRes
Utilities
None
Flooring
Wood/Tile
Appliances
Stove: WolfWasher: Yes
Interior Features
A,AC,InsFloor 1: A welcoming entry foyer introduces the home’s warm and inviting interior, complete with a coat closet and conveniently located powder room. Just off the foyer, a private office with pocket doors provides a quiet and functional work-from-home retreat. The home then opens into a bright, airy kitchen featuring Sub-Zero refrigeration, a Wolf range, Bosch dishwasher, and thoughtfully designed workspace ideal for both everyday living and entertaining.
The open-concept layout flows seamlessly into the main living area, where soft coastal finishes, beautiful wood flooring, and abundant natural light create a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere. A gas fireplace anchors the living room, while a step down leads to a secondary sitting and dining area with wet bar, beverage refrigerator, and ice maker. Large windows and direct access to the pool and outdoor entertaining areas through French doors create a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living, allowing the beautifully landscaped grounds to become an extension of the home itself.Floor 2: The second level offers two thoughtfully designed bedroom suites filled with natural light and elevated by recent renovations. One guest bedroom is spacious enough to accommodate either a king bed or two twins and is served by a beautifully remodeled bathroom with a tub and shower combination. A hallway closet discreetly houses a washer and dryer, adding convenience to the upper level.
The primary suite features vaulted ceilings and a Juliet balcony overlooking the yard, pool, wisteria-covered dining area, and pool cabana beyond. Warm natural light and soft finishes create a calm and inviting retreat, while dual closets provide generous storage. The recently renovated en suite bathroom includes a large walk-in shower and refined finishes that blend timeless Nantucket character with modern comfort.
Basement
The lower level provides an additional gathering space designed for relaxed entertaining and comfortable guest accommodations. An entertainment area offers direct access to a private lower-level courtyard framed by attractive stonework and mature privet hedges. Two additional bedrooms are located on this leveleach with access to recently renovated bathrooms featuring beautifully tiled walk-in showers and updated finishes. The lower level offers excellent separation and flexibility for guests while maintaining the home’s cohesivepolished aesthetic.
Lot Features
See Deed Book 1514 Page 245, Easements Bk 909 Pg 23 and Bk 861 Pg 188, Restrictions Bk 1043 Pg 50Ample
Additional MLS Details
SewerTwn
ZoningR20
Tax Year2026
BasementThe lower level provides an additional gathering space designed for relaxed entertaining and comfortable guest accommodations. An entertainment area offers direct access to a private lower-level courtyard framed by attractive stonework and mature privet hedges. Two additional bedrooms are located on this level, each with access to recently renovated bathrooms featuring beautifully tiled walk-in showers and updated finishes. The lower level offers excellent separation and flexibility for guests while maintaining the home’s cohesive, polished aesthetic.
FlooringWood/Tile
Garage YNfalse
LINK Psf2706.4996
FurnishedUnfurnished
Owner NameHigh Tide Homes LLC
AppliancesStove: Wolf, Washer: Yes
Rooms Total9
Lot FeaturesSee Deed Book 1514 Page 245, Easements Bk 909 Pg 23 and Bk 861 Pg 188, Restrictions Bk 1043 Pg 50, Ample
Water SourceTown
On Market Date2026-06-10
Parcel Number592
Tax Map Number41
Pool Private YNfalse
Tax Annual Amount16041
Interior FeaturesA,AC,Ins, Floor 1: A welcoming entry foyer introduces the home’s warm and inviting interior, complete with a coat closet and conveniently located powder room. Just off the foyer, a private office with pocket doors provides a quiet and functional work-from-home retreat. The home then opens into a bright, airy kitchen featuring Sub-Zero refrigeration, a Wolf range, Bosch dishwasher, and thoughtfully designed workspace ideal for both everyday living and entertaining.
The open-concept layout flows seamlessly into the main living area, where soft coastal finishes, beautiful wood flooring, and abundant natural light create a relaxed yet sophisticated atmosphere. A gas fireplace anchors the living room, while a step down leads to a secondary sitting and dining area with wet bar, beverage refrigerator, and ice maker. Large windows and direct access to the pool and outdoor entertaining areas through French doors create a seamless connection between indoor and outdoor living, allowing the beautifully landscaped grounds to become an extension of the home itself., Floor 2: The second level offers two thoughtfully designed bedroom suites filled with natural light and elevated by recent renovations. One guest bedroom is spacious enough to accommodate either a king bed or two twins and is served by a beautifully remodeled bathroom with a tub and shower combination. A hallway closet discreetly houses a washer and dryer, adding convenience to the upper level.
The primary suite features vaulted ceilings and a Juliet balcony overlooking the yard, pool, wisteria-covered dining area, and pool cabana beyond. Warm natural light and soft finishes create a calm and inviting retreat, while dual closets provide generous storage. The recently renovated en suite bathroom includes a large walk-in shower and refined finishes that blend timeless Nantucket character with modern comfort.
Tax Assessed Value3362800
Fireplace FeaturesGas
Original List Price7995000
LINK Listing Dwell2None
Original Entry Timestamp2025-10-07T16:47:42.070Z
Listing Agent
Brian Sullivan
Fisher Real Estate
Price History
| Date | Event | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 11, 2026 | Listed | $7,995,000 |
Sales History
| Date | Sale Price | List Price | Buyer | MLS # |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dec 10, 2015 | $3,275,000 | $3,695,000 | High Tide Homes LLC | 80809 |
| Sep 10, 2009 | $2,400,000 | $2,900,000 | Winwest Partners LLC | 72650 |
Tax History
| Year | Tax Amount | Assessed Value | Land | Improvements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $16,041 | $3,362,800 | — | — |
Market Context
West of Town Avg
$5,676,000
West of Town Median
$3,990,000
Island Avg
$6,935,068
Island Median
$4,950,000
Property Context
Wetlands NearbyNo
Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.
MLS Listing #92676 — Data as of 2026-07-03