← All properties
Photo 11 / 34

26 Milk Street (Lot 2), Nantucket MA 02554

ActiveTown1 FamilySingle Family Residence
$3,150,000

$2,944 / sqft

Bedrooms

3

Bathrooms

2

Sq Ft

1,070

Lot

0.117 acres

Year Built

1900

Days on Market

177

Description

The Garden Cottage offers three bedrooms, two full baths, a galley kitchen, and an inviting open-concept living and dining area. It was completely renovated at the end of 2025 with interiors by Melanie Gowen Design, combining modern day amenities with preserved historic charm. Ample remaining ground cover allows possibilities for expansion, or enjoy the large garden and multiple outdoor spaces, which include a private side patio, a backyard bricked terrace seating area, front gardens, and front patio perfect for outdoor dining under a pergola. There is private off-street parking for two vehicles. Included in the sale are proposed architectural plans by Nantucket architect Ben Normand, envisioning an expansion to a four-bedroom, four-bath home—maximizing the generous remaining ground cover on its own 5,000± sq. ft. lot. The cottage currently has a footprint of approximately 670± sq. ft. with about 1,370± sq. ft. of additional ground cover available. Three zone air conditioning system is a combination of central ducted and mini split ductless. This turnkey property is being sold fully furnished, ready for immediate occupancy for personal use or lucrative rental opportunity.

Property Details

MLS #92730
StatusActive
Property Type1 Family
Sub TypeSingle Family Residence
NeighborhoodTown
MLS AreaTown
CityNantucket
StateMA
Zip02554
List Price$3,150,000
Original List Price$3,250,000
Price / Sq Ft$2,944
Bedrooms3
Full Baths2
Half Baths0
Total Rooms5
Living Area1,070 sqft
Lot Size0.117 acres
Year Built1900
Days on Market177
ZoningROH
FurnishedFurnished
Fireplaces1
PoolNo
GarageNo
SewerTwn
Water SourceTown
Second DwellingP/Sd
OwnerTimothy and Julianna Mackie / CEDAR & STONE HS LLC
Parcel #37
Tax Map #42.3.3
Tax Year2025
On Market DateNov 6, 2025
First ListedMay 4, 2026
Last UpdatedMay 4, 2026
Latitude41.2795158
Longitude-70.1055576

Heating

GFHW

Parking

Off street parking for 2 vehicles

Exterior

PatioGarden

View

NoneRes

Utilities

Cbl

Flooring

2

Appliances

Stove: BoschWasher: LG (washer/dryer combo)

Interior Features

A,AC,Disp,Ins,IrrFloor 1: The primary living room space features many windows with views onto the gardens, built-in bookcases, and a large cozy fireplace with flat screen smart tv above. A dining table with banquette and chairs bathes in sunlight along the rear patio facing windows. A well planned galley kitchen provides functionality for cooking and entertaining, with appliances smartly concealed behind custom cabinetry panels. The farm sink and butler's pantry-like shelving and cabinetry provides storage. Marble countertops and slate floor, Rohl fixtures, and dimmable architectural recessed lighting. At the rear of the house is a spacious primary suite and en suite bathroom with a large walk-in shower. A second full bath and laundry built in under the stairs smartly uses the space and is convenient on the way to the second floor.Floor 2: The second floor has two bedrooms and a small landing area. The twin bedroom has a built-in bed with twin trundle pullout. The second bedroom is a spacious larger suite featuring a king bed, built-in window seat, daybed, closet, and views overlooking the garden and grounds.

Foundation

block

Basement

A full unfinished basement with a second washer/dryer is accessible via bulkhead stairs from side yard.

Lot Features

Landscaping easementyes

Additional MLS Details

SewerTwn
ZoningROH
Tax Year2025
BasementA full unfinished basement with a second washer/dryer is accessible via bulkhead stairs from side yard.
Flooring2
Garage YNfalse
LINK Psf2943.9252
FurnishedFurnished
Owner NameTimothy and Julianna Mackie / CEDAR & STONE HS LLC
AppliancesStove: Bosch, Washer: LG (washer/dryer combo)
Rooms Total5
Lot FeaturesLandscaping easement, yes
Water SourceTown
On Market Date2025-11-06
Parcel Number37
Tax Map Number42.3.3
Pool Private YNfalse
Interior FeaturesA,AC,Disp,Ins,Irr, Floor 1: The primary living room space features many windows with views onto the gardens, built-in bookcases, and a large cozy fireplace with flat screen smart tv above. A dining table with banquette and chairs bathes in sunlight along the rear patio facing windows. A well planned galley kitchen provides functionality for cooking and entertaining, with appliances smartly concealed behind custom cabinetry panels. The farm sink and butler's pantry-like shelving and cabinetry provides storage. Marble countertops and slate floor, Rohl fixtures, and dimmable architectural recessed lighting. At the rear of the house is a spacious primary suite and en suite bathroom with a large walk-in shower. A second full bath and laundry built in under the stairs smartly uses the space and is convenient on the way to the second floor., Floor 2: The second floor has two bedrooms and a small landing area. The twin bedroom has a built-in bed with twin trundle pullout. The second bedroom is a spacious larger suite featuring a king bed, built-in window seat, daybed, closet, and views overlooking the garden and grounds.
Fireplace Features1
Foundation Detailsblock
Original List Price3250000
LINK Listing Dwell2P/Sd
Price Change Timestamp2026-02-26T18:31:25.640Z
Original Entry Timestamp2025-11-05T19:55:25.827Z

Listing Agent

Melanie Gowen

William Raveis Nantucket

Price History

DateEventPriceChange
May 4, 2026Listed$3,150,000

Market Context

Town Avg

$5,409,833

Town Median

$4,772,500

Island Avg

$6,064,676

Island Median

$4,299,000

Property Context

Wetlands NearbyNo

Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.

MLS Listing #92730 — Data as of 2026-05-04