← All properties
1 / 24
1 / 246 Gull Island Lane, Nantucket MA 02554
ActiveTown1 FamilySingle Family Residence
$10,850,000
$2,978 / sqft
Bedrooms
6
Bathrooms
6 + 1 half
Sq Ft
3,643
Lot
0.1105 acres
Year Built
1780
Days on Market
12
Description
Meticulously restored antique residence set in an exceptional location within the Old Historic District, six bedrooms, seven working fireplaces, and three fully finished levels of living. The home features off-street parking, a finished garage, and inviting outdoor spaces ideal for entertaining. Known as the original Hannah Gardner House, built circa 1780; it has undergone an extraordinarily thorough restoration, executed to the highest specifications and standards retaining its original wavy glass windows, wide board floors and raised paneling throughout-details rarely offered in a property of this era. Ideally situated on the west side of town, the home enjoys a highly desirable setting within the Old Historic District, providing easy access to Main Street, Brant Point, Cliff, and all that downtown Nantucket has to offer.
Property Details
MLS #92925
StatusActive
Property Type1 Family
Sub TypeSingle Family Residence
NeighborhoodTown
MLS AreaTown
CityNantucket
StateMA
Zip02554
List Price$10,850,000
Price / Sq Ft$2,978
Bedrooms6
Full Baths6
Half Baths1
Total Rooms11
Living Area3,643 sqft
Lot Size0.1105 acres
Year Built1780
Days on Market12
ZoningROH
FurnishedPartially
Fireplaces7
PoolNo
GarageYes
SewerTwn
Water SourceTown
Second DwellingP/Sd
OwnerHannah Gardner House LLC
Parcel #51
Tax Map #42.4.3
Annual Tax$14,900
Assessed Value$2,077,700
Tax Year2026
On Market DateApr 21, 2026
First ListedMay 4, 2026
Last UpdatedMay 4, 2026
Latitude41.2869697
Longitude-70.1028656
Heating
GFHA
Parking
3 Cars
Exterior
GardenPatioPorch
View
NoneRes
Utilities
Cbl
Flooring
Wood & Marble
Appliances
Stove: WolfWasher: "2" Speed Queen
Interior Features
A,AC,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: Step into a welcoming entryway with a striking front staircase and original raised paneling that sets the tone for the rest of the home. The living room features a fireplace, creating a warm and inviting gathering space. A first-floor guest suite offers exceptional privacy with its own fireplace, private bath with shower, and separate entrance to the yard and gardens.
The formal dining room, complete with fireplace and beehive oven overlooks a beautiful rose garden, while a charming library with fireplace and custom built shelves provides the perfect retreat for reading or quiet work. A wet bar with wine cooler and pass-through to the kitchen makes entertaining effortless and is conveniently located near the rear stairwell.
The light-filled kitchen features a breakfast area, marble countertops and backsplash, and stunning herringbone flooring, complemented by state-of-the-art appliances including a Wolf range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, and Bosch dishwasher.
A well-appointed laundry room with marble flooring offers direct access to the driveway and the yard and includes two washer and dryers for added convenience. Additional features include custom pantry storage and a powder room.Floor 2: The upstairs landing has a large window that brings in warm western light and overlooks the charming cobblestone lane. Front bedroom suite with original raised paneling and fireplace, large private bath with free standing Waterworks polished nickel tub next to a wood burning fireplace, a separate marble shower stall, make up area and European marble pedestal sink. Middle bedroom with fireplace & original raised paneling has a dedicated bathroom with a windowed marble shower. The rear bedroom serves as a serene primary suite with a cathedral ceiling that creates a bright, open feel, a walk-in closet with custom shelving, and a private bath with a marble shower—offering a comfortable and private retreat within the home. A rear stairwell leads to the third floor.Floor 3: Flexible living space with vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and original wide board flooring, giving it a warm, relaxed feel for overflow living space. From here you can access the roof walk. This level also includes a guest bedroom with a private marble bath and glass-enclosed shower that has steeple views!
Foundation
Brick
Basement
Brick lined wine roombonus room with with natural light and interior & exterior access.
Lot Features
UnknownLandscaped w/Goshen stone patio, rose garden, arbor & mahogany fencing
Additional MLS Details
SewerTwn
ZoningROH
Tax Year2026
BasementBrick lined wine room, bonus room with with natural light and interior & exterior access.
FlooringWood & Marble
Garage YNtrue
LINK Psf2978.3145
FurnishedPartially
Owner NameHannah Gardner House LLC
AppliancesStove: Wolf, Washer: "2" Speed Queen
Rooms Total11
Lot FeaturesUnknown, Landscaped w/Goshen stone patio, rose garden, arbor & mahogany fencing
Water SourceTown
On Market Date2026-04-21
Parcel Number51
Tax Map Number42.4.3
Pool Private YNfalse
Tax Annual Amount14900
Interior FeaturesA,AC,Ins,Irr,OSh, Floor 1: Step into a welcoming entryway with a striking front staircase and original raised paneling that sets the tone for the rest of the home. The living room features a fireplace, creating a warm and inviting gathering space. A first-floor guest suite offers exceptional privacy with its own fireplace, private bath with shower, and separate entrance to the yard and gardens.
The formal dining room, complete with fireplace and beehive oven overlooks a beautiful rose garden, while a charming library with fireplace and custom built shelves provides the perfect retreat for reading or quiet work. A wet bar with wine cooler and pass-through to the kitchen makes entertaining effortless and is conveniently located near the rear stairwell.
The light-filled kitchen features a breakfast area, marble countertops and backsplash, and stunning herringbone flooring, complemented by state-of-the-art appliances including a Wolf range, Sub-Zero refrigerator, and Bosch dishwasher.
A well-appointed laundry room with marble flooring offers direct access to the driveway and the yard and includes two washer and dryers for added convenience. Additional features include custom pantry storage and a powder room., Floor 2: The upstairs landing has a large window that brings in warm western light and overlooks the charming cobblestone lane. Front bedroom suite with original raised paneling and fireplace, large private bath with free standing Waterworks polished nickel tub next to a wood burning fireplace, a separate marble shower stall, make up area and European marble pedestal sink. Middle bedroom with fireplace & original raised paneling has a dedicated bathroom with a windowed marble shower. The rear bedroom serves as a serene primary suite with a cathedral ceiling that creates a bright, open feel, a walk-in closet with custom shelving, and a private bath with a marble shower—offering a comfortable and private retreat within the home. A rear stairwell leads to the third floor., Floor 3: Flexible living space with vaulted ceilings, exposed beams, and original wide board flooring, giving it a warm, relaxed feel for overflow living space. From here you can access the roof walk. This level also includes a guest bedroom with a private marble bath and glass-enclosed shower that has steeple views!
Tax Assessed Value2077700
Fireplace Features7
Foundation DetailsBrick
Original List Price10850000
LINK Listing Dwell2P/Sd
Original Entry Timestamp2026-03-12T12:05:10.263Z
Listing Agent
Mary Taaffe & Kathy Gallaher
Maury People Sotheby's International Realty
Price History
| Date | Event | Price | Change |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 4, 2026 | Listed | $10,850,000 |
Sales History
| Date | Sale Price | List Price | Buyer | MLS # |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 3, 2015 | $1,290,000 | $1,400,000 | Anjonic Real Estae 13 CO LLP | 80020 |
Tax History
| Year | Tax Amount | Assessed Value | Land | Improvements |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | $14,900 | $2,077,700 | — | — |
Market Context
Town Avg
$5,409,833
Town Median
$4,772,500
Island Avg
$6,064,676
Island Median
$4,299,000
Property Context
Wetlands NearbyNo
Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.
MLS Listing #92925 — Data as of 2026-05-04