1 / 34

4 Gay Street, Nantucket MA 02554

ActiveTown1 FamilySingle Family Residence

$8,950,000

$2,091 / sqft

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

5 + 1 half

Sq Ft

4,280

Lot

0.12 acres

Year Built

1825

Days on Market

Description

Tucked between the pulse of downtown and the calm of a neighboring park, 4 Gay Street is a rare in-town jewel that pairs historic authenticity with thoughtful, high-quality renovation. Originally built in 1825 and fully restored with craftsmanship at every turn, this home lives like a page out of Nantucket’s past—curved walls, heart pine floors, handmade woodwork—yet delivers modern ease and luxurious comfort. The result of two years of meticulous craftsmanship by the Carey Company and hand-selected finishes by renowned Nantucket designer Audrey Sterk, the home strikes a flawless balance between enduring beauty and modern livability. From the gas lanterns flickering along the stone walkway to the richly designed interiors and multiple fireplaces, every detail reflects timeless Nantucket character. Step inside from the spacious wraparound porch and immediately sense the intimacy and grandeur of a bygone era—yet with a warm, livable layout that includes both formal and casual spaces. The property includes a post-and-beam garage with carriage doors and beautifully designed landscaping throughout. A true masterwork of restoration and design, 4 Gay Street is the kind of Nantucket home that rarely comes to market—inviting you to live right in the heart of Town without ever feeling in the middle of it.

Property Details

MLS #93045

StatusActive

Property Type1 Family

Sub TypeSingle Family Residence

NeighborhoodTown

MLS AreaTown

CityNantucket

StateMA

Zip02554

List Price$8,950,000

Price / Sq Ft$2,091

Bedrooms4

Full Baths5

Half Baths1

Total Rooms9

Living Area4,280 sqft

Lot Size0.12 acres

Year Built1825

Days on Market12

ZoningROH

FurnishedUnfurnished

FireplacesThree

PoolNo

GarageNo

SewerTwn

Water SourceTown

Second DwellingNone

OwnerShellacked LLC

Parcel #19

Tax Map #42.3.4

Annual Tax$13,976

Assessed Value$2,655,500

Tax Year2026

On Market DateApr 21, 2026

First ListedMay 4, 2026

Last UpdatedMay 4, 2026

Latitude41.2849307

Longitude-70.1012979

Heating

OFHA

Parking

Off Street parking from Quince Street

Exterior

PorchDeckPatio

View

NoneRes

Utilities

Cbl

Flooring

Wood/Tile

Appliances

Stove: YesWasher: Yes

Interior Features

A,ACFloor 1: A welcoming wraparound porch leads into the elegant entry hall, showcasing a blend of beautifully restored ceilings and windows with updated lighting. To the left, a stunning dining room comfortably seats ten beneath vintage light fixtures, with original door hardware and historic murals setting a warm, curated tone. To the right, a grand formal room with paneled walls and an oversized hearth features a granite mantle and exquisite detailing. Between the dining room and the kitchen sits a cozy den with fireplace and reading nook. Continuing to the back of the home, the custom kitchen is bright and modern, centered around a large island and complemented by high-end appliances, dual dishwashers, and a five-burner stove. Glass shelving and oversized sliding windows bring in light and overlook the backyard. A charming eat-in breakfast area and a beautifully detailed butler’s pantry—with wine fridge, built-ins, and space for an ice maker—elevate the experience. The rear of the home includes a side entrance with mudroom, a designer half bath, and a separate laundry room with a farmer’s sink. Two separate staircases lead to the second floor.Floor 2: The second level offers a graceful primary suite with transom windows, custom closets, and heart pine ceilings. A large en suite bathroom completes the retreat. Two more guest bedrooms, each with ample closets and full baths, are thoughtfully placed throughout the floor. Another room with a gas fireplace and beautifully restored original tiles serves as a den.Floor 3: Accessed from the rear staircase, the third floor opens into a quiet landing with desk area and custom details. A full bath and a bedroom with closet complete the level, while a functional roof walk provides sweeping views of downtown and the harbor beyond—offering yet another unique element to this historic and beautifully executed property.

Basement

Unfinished 1600 sq ft basement

Lot Features

See Deed Book 1954 Page 200

Additional MLS Details

SewerTwn

ZoningROH

Tax Year2026

BasementUnfinished 1600 sq ft basement

FlooringWood/Tile

Garage YNfalse

LINK Psf2091.1214

FurnishedUnfurnished

Owner NameShellacked LLC

AppliancesStove: Yes, Washer: Yes

Rooms Total9

Lot FeaturesSee Deed Book 1954 Page 200

Water SourceTown

On Market Date2026-04-21

Parcel Number19

Tax Map Number42.3.4

Pool Private YNfalse

Tax Annual Amount13976

Interior FeaturesA,AC, Floor 1: A welcoming wraparound porch leads into the elegant entry hall, showcasing a blend of beautifully restored ceilings and windows with updated lighting. To the left, a stunning dining room comfortably seats ten beneath vintage light fixtures, with original door hardware and historic murals setting a warm, curated tone. To the right, a grand formal room with paneled walls and an oversized hearth features a granite mantle and exquisite detailing. Between the dining room and the kitchen sits a cozy den with fireplace and reading nook. Continuing to the back of the home, the custom kitchen is bright and modern, centered around a large island and complemented by high-end appliances, dual dishwashers, and a five-burner stove. Glass shelving and oversized sliding windows bring in light and overlook the backyard. A charming eat-in breakfast area and a beautifully detailed butler’s pantry—with wine fridge, built-ins, and space for an ice maker—elevate the experience. The rear of the home includes a side entrance with mudroom, a designer half bath, and a separate laundry room with a farmer’s sink. Two separate staircases lead to the second floor., Floor 2: The second level offers a graceful primary suite with transom windows, custom closets, and heart pine ceilings. A large en suite bathroom completes the retreat. Two more guest bedrooms, each with ample closets and full baths, are thoughtfully placed throughout the floor. Another room with a gas fireplace and beautifully restored original tiles serves as a den., Floor 3: Accessed from the rear staircase, the third floor opens into a quiet landing with desk area and custom details. A full bath and a bedroom with closet complete the level, while a functional roof walk provides sweeping views of downtown and the harbor beyond—offering yet another unique element to this historic and beautifully executed property.

Tax Assessed Value2655500

Fireplace FeaturesThree

Original List Price8950000

LINK Listing Dwell2None

Listing Agent

Brian Sullivan

Fisher Real Estate

Price History

Date	Event	Price	Change
May 4, 2026	Listed	$8,950,000

Sales History

Date	Sale Price	List Price	Buyer	MLS #
Oct 23, 2023	$4,450,000	$4,395,000	Shellacked LLC	90789

Tax History

Year	Tax Amount	Assessed Value	Land	Improvements
2026	$13,976	$2,655,500	—	—

Market Context

Town Avg

$5,409,833

Town Median

$4,772,500

Island Avg

$6,064,676

Island Median

$4,299,000

Property Context

Wetlands NearbyNo

Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.

MLS Listing #93045 — Data as of 2026-05-04