1 / 47

36 Warrens Landing Road, Nantucket MA 02554

Active1 FamilySingle Family Residence

$19,950,000

$3,075 / sqft

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

8 + 3 half

Sq Ft

6,488

Lot

3 acres

Year Built

2016

Days on Market

150

Description

Set across three private acres in Eel Point, 36 Warrens Landing Road is a rare Nantucket estate completed in 2017. This remarkable seven-bedroom compound pairs exceptional craftsmanship and sophisticated design with an extraordinary sense of scale, privacy, and connection to the landscape. Elevated views extend toward Madaket Harbor and the ocean, while expansive lawns, mature landscaping, and a resort-like pool and spa create an exceptional setting for island living. More than 3,900 square feet of meticulously designed outdoor entertaining space offers multiple settings for relaxation and gatherings. A gracious screened-in porch, covered porches, expansive decks, and a generous patio provide spaces for morning coffee, sunset cocktails, poolside gatherings, and elegant al fresco dining, all thoughtfully positioned to embrace Nantucket’s western views. The 6,488-square-foot main residence is complemented by a distinctive indoor/outdoor pool house with dual cabanas and an oversized two-car garage with a finished studio above. Thoughtfully orchestrated architecture and grounds create a private compound equally suited to intimate family gatherings and grand-scale entertaining. More than a residence, 36 Warrens Landing Road is an exceptional Nantucket retreat where architecture, landscape, and the island’s natural beauty converge.

Property Details

MLS #93127

StatusActive

Property Type1 Family

Sub TypeSingle Family Residence

MLS AreaEel Point

CityNantucket

StateMA

Zip02554

List Price$19,950,000

Price / Sq Ft$3,075

Bedrooms7

Full Baths8

Half Baths3

Total Rooms19

Living Area6,488 sqft

Lot Size3 acres

Year Built2016

Days on Market150

ZoningLUG2

FurnishedUnfurnished

Fireplaces2

PoolNo

GarageYes

SewerSeptic Tank

Water SourceWell

Second DwellingP/Sd

OwnerFinnegan

Parcel #44

Tax Map #38

Assessed Value$5,360,800

Tax Year2026

On Market DateMay 28, 2026

First ListedMay 29, 2026

Last UpdatedNov 1, 2026

Latitude41.2854157

Longitude-70.1835268

Heating

GFHA

Parking

Oversized 2-Car Garage plus multiple driveway turnouts

Exterior

DeckPatioPorchP/PoolH/TubGymGarden

View

HbrOcean

Utilities

Cbl

Flooring

Appliances

Stove: Wolf RangeWasher: Yes

Interior Features

A,AC,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: • The entry opens into a welcoming sitting room with views across the expansive lawn and an adjoining built-in coat room. This level includes three en-suite bedrooms, a laundry room, mudroom, powder room, and access to the screened porch. • The first floor also features the remarkable Barn Room, a warm and dramatic entertaining space centered around an oversized New England fieldstone fireplace. Old-growth oak flooring, vintage hand-hewn American chestnut beams, and a custom staircase leading to an outdoor deck give the room authentic character and rustic elegance.Floor 2: • The primary living level takes full advantage of views toward Madaket Harbor. It includes the kitchen, an impressive pantry, living room, half bath, primary suite, ensuite guest bedroom, and four outdoor decks. • The kitchen is equipped with a Wolf range, Sub-Zero refrigeration and beverage storage, Thermador appliances, and two Bosch dishwashers - making it exceptionally well-suited for entertaining.Floor 3: • A custom staircase leads to a loft and the widow’s walk, where panoramic views extend across Madaket Harbor, Smith’s Point, Eel Point, Tuckernuck, Nantucket Sound, and the surrounding landscape.

Foundation

Poured Concrete

Basement

• The finished lower level provides two additional bedroomstwo bathroomstwo separate living areasand a private gym—offering flexible space for guestsrecreationor extended family.

Lot Features

Large Lawn and Fields

Additional MLS Details

SewerSeptic Tank

ZoningLUG2

Tax Year2026

Basement• The finished lower level provides two additional bedrooms, two bathrooms, two separate living areas, and a private gym—offering flexible space for guests, recreation, or extended family.

Flooring3

Garage YNtrue

LINK Psf3074.9075

FurnishedUnfurnished

Owner NameFinnegan

AppliancesStove: Wolf Range, Washer: Yes

Rooms Total19

Lot FeaturesLarge Lawn and Fields

Water SourceWell

On Market Date2026-05-28

Parcel Number44

Tax Map Number38

Pool Private YNfalse

Interior FeaturesA,AC,Ins,Irr,OSh, Floor 1: • The entry opens into a welcoming sitting room with views across the expansive lawn and an adjoining built-in coat room. This level includes three en-suite bedrooms, a laundry room, mudroom, powder room, and access to the screened porch. • The first floor also features the remarkable Barn Room, a warm and dramatic entertaining space centered around an oversized New England fieldstone fireplace. Old-growth oak flooring, vintage hand-hewn American chestnut beams, and a custom staircase leading to an outdoor deck give the room authentic character and rustic elegance., Floor 2: • The primary living level takes full advantage of views toward Madaket Harbor. It includes the kitchen, an impressive pantry, living room, half bath, primary suite, ensuite guest bedroom, and four outdoor decks. • The kitchen is equipped with a Wolf range, Sub-Zero refrigeration and beverage storage, Thermador appliances, and two Bosch dishwashers - making it exceptionally well-suited for entertaining., Floor 3: • A custom staircase leads to a loft and the widow’s walk, where panoramic views extend across Madaket Harbor, Smith’s Point, Eel Point, Tuckernuck, Nantucket Sound, and the surrounding landscape.

Tax Assessed Value5360800

Fireplace Features2

Foundation DetailsPoured Concrete

Original List Price19950000

LINK Listing Dwell2P/Sd

Listing Agent

John McGarr

Maury People Sotheby's International Realty

Price History

Date	Event	Price	Change
May 29, 2026	Listed	$19,950,000

Sales History

Date	Sale Price	List Price	Buyer	MLS #
Jul 11, 2012	$975,000	$999,000	Finnegan	75886

Market Context

Island Avg

$7,489,964

Island Median

$4,950,000

Property Context

Wetlands NearbyNo

Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.

MLS Listing #93127 — Data as of 2026-11-01