1 / 71

16 Black Fish Lane, Nantucket MA 02554

ActiveSconset1 FamilySingle Family Residence

$7,995,000

$1,555 / sqft

Bedrooms

Bathrooms

6 + 1 half

Sq Ft

5,143

Lot

0.46 acres

Year Built

2014

Days on Market

Description

Set on Blackfish Lane, an established ’Sconset street moments from the market, village, and shoreline, this thoughtfully designed retreat by Botticelli & Pohl enjoys a beautiful setting framed by mature plantings and trees. A five-bedroom main residence and detached one-bedroom cottage offer generous accommodations for family and guests. White oak detailing brings warmth and texture to the interiors, while every aspect of the design and layout has been carefully considered, pairing exceptional craftsmanship with effortless functionality. A geothermal system complements the home’s thoughtful design. At the heart of the main residence, an open kitchen and living area connects naturally to expansive outdoor spaces. The large, manicured yard offers exceptional privacy, with a pool and spa, a regulation bocce court, and inviting areas for dining, lounging, and entertaining. The guest cottage incorporates a garage and first-floor cabana amenities serving the pool, opening directly onto the lawn and creating a seamless connection to the outdoor living spaces. Three finished levels in the main residence balance shared living spaces with quiet retreats. A first-floor primary suite offers comfort and convenience, while additional bedrooms upstairs welcome family and guests. The lower level provides a secondary living area and a bunk room with four full beds. Together, the home, cottage, and private grounds create a setting for long summer days and gatherings that become lasting island traditions.

Property Details

MLS #93516

StatusActive

Property Type1 Family

Sub TypeSingle Family Residence

NeighborhoodSconset

MLS AreaSconset

CityNantucket

StateMA

Zip02554

List Price$7,995,000

Price / Sq Ft$1,555

Bedrooms6

Full Baths6

Half Baths1

Total Rooms8

Living Area5,143 sqft

Lot Size0.46 acres

Year Built2014

Days on Market4

ZoningSR20

FurnishedUnfurnished

FireplacesGas Fireplace

PoolNo

GarageYes

SewerTwn

Water SourceTown

Second DwellingE/Sd

OwnerCalhoun, James A. Jr. & Jennifer A.

Parcel #116

Tax Map #73

Annual Tax$19,883.44

Assessed Value$3,927,200

Tax Year2027

On Market DateOct 21, 2026

First ListedOct 21, 2026

Last UpdatedNov 1, 2026

Latitude41.2668787

Longitude-69.9719423

Heating

GFHA

Parking

Yes- Shelled driveway with convenient parking for two and near to the side door mudroom laundry entrance.

Exterior

P/PoolH/TubDeckGardenPatioPorch

View

NoneRes

Utilities

Cbl

Flooring

Hardwood Oak Floors

Appliances

Stove: 36" Wolf 6 Burner Gas Stove w/ Double OvenWasher: Whirlpool

Interior Features

A,AC,Disp,Ins,Irr,OShFloor 1: The main level is designed around easy summer living, with open gourmet kitchen and living spaces that invite everyone to gather while maintaining a relaxed sense of flow. The interiors connect naturally to the outdoor dining and lounge areas, making it easy to move from breakfast inside to afternoons by the pool and dinner outdoors. The primary suite is also located on this level, with cathedral ceilings and vistas out to your covered porch creating a private retreat with the convenience of first-floor living.Floor 2: The second floor offers three additional bedrooms tucked away from the home’s primary entertaining spaces. Comfortable and private, this level creates welcoming accommodations for family and guests while preserving a sense of separation from the activity below.

Foundation

Concrete Pour with 10' ceilings

Basement

The finished lower level extends the home’s living space with a secondary lounge ideal for movie nightsgamesor simply giving younger guests a place of their own. A bunk room with four full sized built-in bunk beds makes this level particularly well suited for children and visiting friends.

Lot Features

Yes

Additional MLS Details

SewerTwn

ZoningSR20

Tax Year2027

BasementThe finished lower level extends the home’s living space with a secondary lounge ideal for movie nights, games, or simply giving younger guests a place of their own. A bunk room with four full sized built-in bunk beds makes this level particularly well suited for children and visiting friends.

FlooringHardwood Oak Floors

Garage YNtrue

LINK Psf1554.5401

FurnishedUnfurnished

Owner NameCalhoun, James A. Jr. & Jennifer A.

AppliancesStove: 36" Wolf 6 Burner Gas Stove w/ Double Oven, Washer: Whirlpool

Rooms Total8

Lot FeaturesYes

Water SourceTown

On Market Date2026-10-21

Parcel Number116

Tax Map Number73

Pool Private YNfalse

Tax Annual Amount19883.44

Interior FeaturesA,AC,Disp,Ins,Irr,OSh, Floor 1: The main level is designed around easy summer living, with open gourmet kitchen and living spaces that invite everyone to gather while maintaining a relaxed sense of flow. The interiors connect naturally to the outdoor dining and lounge areas, making it easy to move from breakfast inside to afternoons by the pool and dinner outdoors. The primary suite is also located on this level, with cathedral ceilings and vistas out to your covered porch creating a private retreat with the convenience of first-floor living., Floor 2: The second floor offers three additional bedrooms tucked away from the home’s primary entertaining spaces. Comfortable and private, this level creates welcoming accommodations for family and guests while preserving a sense of separation from the activity below.

Tax Assessed Value3927200

Fireplace FeaturesGas Fireplace

Foundation DetailsConcrete Pour with 10' ceilings

Original List Price7995000

LINK Listing Dwell2E/Sd

Original Entry Timestamp2026-10-03T10:53:03.523Z

Listing Agent

Chandra Miller

Maury People Sotheby's International Realty

Price History

Date	Event	Price	Change
Oct 21, 2026	Listed	$7,995,000

Sales History

Date	Sale Price	List Price	Buyer	MLS #
Nov 12, 2013	$1,100,000	$1,100,000	Calhoun	78565

Tax History

Year	Tax Amount	Assessed Value	Land	Improvements
2027	$19,883.44	$3,927,200	—	—

Market Context

Sconset Avg

$9,943,333

Sconset Median

$7,995,000

Island Avg

$7,489,964

Island Median

$4,950,000

Property Context

Wetlands NearbyNo

Source: MassGIS / FEMA NFHL. For informational purposes only — verify with Town of Nantucket.

MLS Listing #93516 — Data as of 2026-11-01